How Do You Know You're Not Insane?

How Do You Know You're Not Insane?

Editorial illustration of Nellie Bly and the asylum on Blackwell's Island. Not a historical photograph.

How do you know whether someone is insane? And, more to the point, how do you know that you aren't?

Imagine being locked in an asylum. You insist there has been a mistake, that you are perfectly sane and that you want to leave. Nobody believes you.

What would you do if the only people who could let you out were the very ones convinced you should stay?

In September 1887, a young woman arrived at a boarding house for women in New York. She called herself Nellie Brown. Her behaviour was strange: she seemed terrified, distrusted everyone around her, and said she could not remember where she had come from.

The women running the boarding house ended up calling the police.

Several doctors examined her and concluded that she was mentally ill. Shortly afterwards she was transferred to the women's asylum on Blackwell's Island, in the East River.

But there was something none of them knew.

Nellie Brown was not ill. She was not even called Nellie Brown.

She was Nellie Bly, a 23-year-old reporter who had got herself committed on purpose to investigate conditions inside the asylum.

And now the genuinely dangerous part was beginning.

Historical portrait of Nellie Bly Nellie Bly, historical portrait (circa 1890). Source: Library of Congress.

Ten days

Before she started, Bly had asked her editor how he planned to get her out once she was inside.

The answer was not especially reassuring: he did not know yet. They would find a way.

Once inside, Bly stopped pretending. She behaved normally, made conversation and answered the questions she was asked. Even so, nobody seemed to reconsider the diagnosis.

What she found was far worse than she had expected.

The patients were given terrible food, endured cold baths, and spent long hours sitting without being allowed to talk. Bly also witnessed mistreatment by the staff.

She met women who seemed perfectly lucid. Some were immigrants who barely spoke English and struggled to explain their situation.

But one thing was especially disturbing: once a woman had been declared ill, her own words seemed to count for very little.

Bly had an advantage most of those patients did not: somebody on the outside knew where she was.

After ten days, a lawyer sent by the paper secured her release.

What happened next

Bly published her investigation in the New York World, under the title Ten Days in a Mad-House.

The account caused an uproar. A grand jury investigated conditions at the asylum and Bly testified about what she had seen. The authorities put more money into patient care and improvements were pushed through at the institution.

The investigation did not fix everything wrong with the system, but it achieved something important: it put the experiences of women who were effectively invisible in front of the public.

And to think it all started with a reporter who wanted to know what was going on behind a set of closed doors.

Nellie Bly could have settled for the rumours. She could have interviewed doctors, read reports and written a piece from the comfort of her desk.

Instead, she decided to go in.

She did not know exactly how they would get her out. She did not know what she would find in there either.

Her curiosity led her to take a risk most of us would probably have avoided.

And that leaves me thinking about something.

How far would you be willing to go to find out something you really want to know?

If a doctor's diagnosis outweighed a patient's own account, it is worth asking how much to trust what the mind reports about itself.

Declaring a woman ill and having that be enough looks a lot like the trials taken apart by a book on witchcraft from 1584.

Bly refused to settle for the reports and went in; I did something far more comfortable when I went to Malta to see the stones.


📬 Enjoyed this article?

Subscribe for the stuff that doesn't make it onto the blog — half-finished ideas, what I'm reading and listening to, behind-the-scenes notes, and the occasional rabbit hole. No spam, just things worth your time.

Join the newsletter →